AMERICAN THEATRE | Are We Promoting Experiences or Serving Communities?


Jay Pension and Anthony S. Rhine

Why does advertising and marketing all the time really feel like a continuing battle in nonprofit theater? One which we slowly appear to be dropping. Why can we hold listening to about engagement, the engagement economic system, and humanities engagement? How does engagement work? Do advertising and marketing and engagement have something to do with one another? The solutions to those questions is probably not as laborious to seek out as you would possibly assume. 

Oxford College Press has launched our new e book, Easy methods to Market the Arts: A Sensible Strategy for the 21st Century. The e book explores these questions and extra by rigorously strolling by means of the standard theories of selling, detailing why the nonprofit arts battle so mightily with attempting to use them efficiently and explaining how the assemble of engagement might be applied efficiently. We name the strategy The Engagement Edge and use the mannequin to display a basic shift in how we are able to serve our communities. The e book particulars loads of case research with interviews (together with Felix Barrett’s Sleep No Extra and the Public Theatre’s engagement program) to discover the ideas however leaves open the distinctive methods wherein theaters can apply this new strategy.  

 Earlier than you dismiss the thought, pondering that your theatre does have an engagement plan, contemplate that almost all nonprofit arts organizations find yourself offering outreach (wherein they bring about artwork into the group) moderately than true engagement wherein group members work with the theatre to facilitate the co-creation of arts experiences. 

When Eugene McCarthy first developed the idea for modern-day advertising and marketing within the 1950’s, the inspiration on which all advertising and marketing right now is constructed, nonprofit arts organizations as we now know them didn’t exist. Nonprofit peculiarities have by no means gibed with the advertising and marketing combine mannequin, referred to as the 4 Ps. This combine, as McCarthy known as it, was like a recipe wherein elements have been blended to create simply the appropriate steadiness. These 4 elements are Product, Worth, Place, and Promotion. The advertising and marketing combine facilities on revenue technology, whereas nonprofit arts organizations exist for the aim of group service. You possibly can see the issue.  Once we use conventional advertising and marketing strategies, we are attempting to promote to the group as a substitute of serving it by means of engagement.  

We aren’t suggesting that anybody ought to cease conducting advertising and marketing that’s proving profitable. Nonetheless, the place there are group members who are usually not but served by a theatre, our assemble of The Engagement Edge is a technique to attain them. As an alternative of the 4 Ps, it makes use of the 4 Es: Expertise, Ease of Entry, Setting, and Schooling.  

Product and Expertise

McCarthy famous that merchandise might be items, providers, or concepts with “the capability to supply the satisfaction, use, or maybe the revenue desired by the buyer.” The fascinating factor is that the buyer doesn’t must know they need one thing. The advertising and marketing supervisor does the evaluation and analysis to know the buyer’s occupied with a product, helps form the product to fulfill shoppers, and communicates an efficient message to shut the sale. To us, this appears at odds with nonprofit arts the place the creation of artwork stays virtually completely on the sole discretion of artists, free from market pressures. As we are saying within the e book, “Though the supervisor could place the inventive product as an artist’s illustration of society, each bit of artwork, whether or not a ballet, symphony, statue, portray, or live performance, has a novel relationship to every shopper.ii” Due to this, we acknowledge that the artwork itself will not be actually a product as our colleagues in advertising and marketing outline that time period. As an alternative, artwork is one thing that exists when it’s skilled by an viewers. 

Punchdrunk’s ‘Sleep No Extra,’ offered by Emursive at The McKittrick Lodge. (Picture by Robin Roemer).

This implies not simply that our audiences “expertise” one thing, since we at the moment are residing within the “expertise economic system,” however that due to the artwork they’ve an expertise. Nearly a century in the past thinker John Dewey gave us the notion of “Artwork as Expertise,” and his prophetic concepts drive The Engagement Edge, which proposes that the humanities expertise begins when somebody first turns into conscious of the artwork and ends when essential and emotional occupied with the artwork now not have priority in a shopper’s thoughts. Arts experiences are extra than simply an hour or two in a darkened room with paintings. As a result of they’re experiences, they’re distinctive to everybody.   

We are saying this within the e book: “You will need to contemplate that the artist conceives artwork as an interpretation or reflection of one thing, even when these viewing it could have a really completely different expertise. The visible arts result in completely different ideas, emotions, and feelings based mostly on the viewer, their circumstances, and their private historical past. All artwork types are in a continuing state of flux, permitting for steady interpretation and appreciation, and might be conceived as a collaborative expertise. The viewers participates in that after a connection has been made, there turns into an inward statement, and the encounter turns into a private expertise.” 

We like to consider it like this: a tube of toothpaste doesn’t require a toothbrusher as a way to be a product. A lodge room lease remains to be a service with or and not using a visitor.  “Artwork, nevertheless, doesn’t exist till it happens in an viewers, so it’s neither product nor service. It’s a participatory course of which requires the buyer of the method, and with out whom the artwork turns into merely a rehearsal or paint on a canvas.” 

Worth and Ease of Entry 

Worth is the one P that generates precise income. Though we consider worth as being cash, it’s really a bundle of the prices of buying a very good or service. That features issues like effort and time. In advertising and marketing, there are myriad methods we are able to set worth to steadiness with shopper wants.  

Within the nonprofit arts, nevertheless, worth will not be the one assemble that generates income. The nonprofit arts additionally generate income by means of fundraising. Not like most for revenue companies, some nonprofit arts organizations present free arts occasions as their major purpose is service moderately than income. Within the e book, we notice that “as a result of the advertising and marketing combine doesn’t readily incorporate the vagaries of fundraising and fund growth, the standard approaches for making use of pricing technique are stymied by the distinctive nature of the nonprofit arts.” The problem then turns into, how can we appropriately worth the humanities? It’s not about cash. It’s about entry! “The nonprofit arts supervisor should perceive the obstacles to entry for group members and make strides to ease that entry, not essentially by altering the financial value of the entry however by participating with the group about their wants.” 

The Delacorte Theater in Central Park, dwelling to The Public’s Free Shakespeare within the Park. (Picture courtesy of The Public Theater).

“Ease of entry is the method of lowering obstacles to assist present entry to an providing. It considers greater than the change between particular person and group. Generally, like when organizations present free choices, there isn’t any change. Even in a free providing from an arts group, obstacles exist that may hinder potential participation from group members. Folks expertise various ranges of ease of entry relying on what number of obstacles exist, how these obstacles impression them individually, and the way these obstacles happen to them.iii This mixture of obstacles implies that some individuals have a better time accessing arts organizations’ choices than others. Ease of entry focuses on lowering obstacles for all present and potential viewers members.” 

Place and Setting 

For each nonprofit arts marketer following McCarthy’s 4 Ps, the P of Place is nearly ineffective. Place refers to all of the touchpoints a services or products meets between its starting of creation to its consumption by a shopper. Within the industrial world this implies distribution. Corporations contract with suppliers, distributors, salespeople, shippers, warehouses, promoters, distributors, retailers, servicers, restore amenities, and on and on. Business merchandise can go by means of scores of fingers earlier than attending to the buyer. Within the nonprofit arts, there are not any distribution networks. Positive, perhaps a Broadway tour or a service like TicketMaster might be thought of distributors beneath the moniker of Place, however these are industrial enterprises. “There seems to be little or no correlation between the P of place and nonprofit arts advertising and marketing except you contemplate the precise area the place viewing artwork happens to be primarily the complete manifestation of place.” 

We prefer to assume that “the idea of atmosphere will not be solely the bodily place wherein we occupy area but in addition the emotional and psychological elements of that place.” To us, Setting embodies, “the qualities of these areas the place viewers members go throughout the complete means of the expertise. This description refers back to the qualities of locations the place interplay happens from the second the buyer turns into conscious of the providing as much as, and even after the purpose when, the complete inventive expertise is consummated.” Though probably the most intense a part of the expertise is probably going the viewing of the artwork, the expertise consists of issues like shopping for the ticket, having a meal earlier than the artwork occasion, the locations one travels by means of to get to the artwork, and even the atmosphere for a dialogue concerning the artwork after its viewing.  “We can’t management the qualities of all these environments, however a stable plan considers probably the most frequent touchpoint environments and seeks to manage or quasi-control as many qualities as potential.” 

Promotion and Schooling 

“The time period promotion is usually probably the most misunderstood within the advertising and marketing combine, as it’s the basis upon which McCarthy’s scientific strategy was constructed, promoting. In reality, promotion refers back to the communications and communication methodology used to disseminate details about the product. Although it consists of communication technique, design, and supply by means of varied chosen communication channels, its basic idea is to successfully persuade the buyer.” 

“Yearly, tons of of billions of {dollars} are spent on promoting in the US alone. That’s an unbelievable sum of cash devoted to convincing us to make purchases. When for-profit companies use promotional techniques, they work; so, it is sensible that nonprofit arts organizations would need to assemble prospects by means of conventional promotional channels. Though not all for-profit companies that promote merchandise flip a revenue annually, the overwhelming majority of people who do use promotion to steer individuals to make a purchase order.” 

Occasions Sq. (Picture by Inspiria Outside Promoting.)

The first operate of a nonprofit is service, not revenue for house owners. So, the thought of persuading the very group they’re there to serve is misguided. If a company is actually serving its group, and a few members who might recognize the service are usually not taking part, we argue that the purpose of a nonprofit arts group is to teach the group concerning the service moderately than persuading individuals to reap the benefits of it. In spite of everything, the 501(c)(3) tax code doesn’t point out the humanities; most nonprofit arts organizations obtain nonprofit standing by means of the schooling designation.  

“One of the best educators don’t use schooling as a device to achieve energy, nor do they depend on memorization of information as their mode of educating.iv As an alternative, they arrange eventualities wherein college students make the connections and discoveries.v Since data is available to individuals, the educator’s function is to assist learners develop easy methods to uncover, analyze, and synthesize data for themselves.” 

“Not solely does schooling permit an arts group to interact with its group as by no means earlier than, however it additionally permits an arts group to serve the group in a brand new means. We will shift the hassle and assets spent persuading potential viewers members to attend, remodeling that vitality into one thing extra helpful. The transfer from promotion to schooling permits arts organizations to supply worth to the group, even earlier than a purchase order happens.” 

“Some arts organizations already implement this with their patrons (who’ve bought tickets) however do little for individuals who lack arts schooling or expertise. The purpose is to not create artwork critics, however to assist our communities to find for themselves what they take from the humanities expertise.” 

The Engagement Edge 

So, the 4 Ps are out, and the 4 Es are in, so to talk. That’s the foundation for The Engagement Edge. It’s a course of for permitting whole nonprofit arts organizations to succeed in those that are underserved or not served in any respect. It’s a technique to have most impression. And it’s a means for the nonprofit arts to interrupt a few of the chains of capitalism that problem the essential premise of why the nonprofit arts exist. For these nonprofits who embrace The Engagement Edge, we anticipate to see a really promising future.

Launched in Sept., Easy methods to Market the Arts: A Sensible Strategy for the 21st Century is accessible from Oxford College Press.

Help American Theatre: a simply and thriving theatre ecology begins with data for all. Please be a part of us on this mission by making a donation to our writer, Theatre Communications Group. While you assist American Theatre journal and TCG, you assist a protracted legacy of high quality nonprofit arts journalism. Click on right here to make your totally tax-deductible donation right now!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here